
How to Teach Dogs to Stay Still
Dogs struggle with “stay” because their brains are wired to “follow the pack”—and you’re their pack. To them, staying put while you move feels wrong
Picture this: You’re at the local park, your Labrador gleefully chasing squirrels, and your cheerful "Come!" echoes into the void. Sound familiar? Teaching a reliable recall—"come here"—isn’t just convenient; it’s a safety essential. Here’s how to make it stick, the kind and effective way.
Start indoors where distractions are minimal. Grab your pup’s favorite high-value treat—think diced chicken or string cheese, not just kibble. Crouch down, pat your legs, and enthusiastically call "Bella, come!" in a bright, inviting tone. When she trots over, immediately reward her and shower praise. This taps into operant conditioning: Her action (coming) earns a desirable consequence (treat + affection), making her repeat it. Repeat this 5–10 times daily in short bursts, gradually adding distance.
Now, add mild challenges. Move to your fenced backyard or quiet hallway. Attach a lightweight 15-foot training leash for safety—never yank it to force compliance. Call her while gently backing away, making yourself exciting. If she hesitates, avoid repeating the command; instead, clap or make a kissy noise to regain attention. Reward instantly when she reaches you. This builds stimulus control, ensuring she responds amidst mild environmental distractions like rustling leaves.
Public practice? Crucial for real-world reliability, but remember compliance. Always leash up where required (check city ordinances!), and carry waste bags—scooping poop isn’t just polite; it’s legally mandated in all 50 states. Start in low-traffic areas like empty tennis courts. Use extra-delicious rewards (freeze-dried liver works wonders). If she ignores you, calmly walk over, leash her, and reset—never scold. Punishment teaches dogs that returning to you risks unpleasantness, undermining trust.
Apartment dwellers, take note: A solid recall prevents dashing into hallways or elevators. Practice "emergency recalls" by using a unique cue like "Here now!" paired with jackpot rewards (3–5 treats at once). Consistency matters: If your dog ignores "come" during morning walks but gets rewarded at dusk, confusion sets in.
Culturally, positive reinforcement isn’t a trend—it’s science-backed and ethically non-negotiable. Hitting, yelling, or shock collars violate animal welfare norms across the EU and US, potentially triggering legal intervention. Studies show force increases fear-based aggression. Instead, celebrate small wins: If your terrier glances at you mid-squirrel chase, praise that micro-choice!
Community etiquette ties in too. Always ask permission before letting your dog approach others—even in off-leash zones. Ensure vaccinations (rabies, distemper/parvo) are current; fines for non-compliance can exceed $500 in states like California. If your recall fails near roads, immediately practice leash drills for 48 hours before re-testing freedom.
Troubleshooting? If progress stalls, lower distractions or raise treat value. For stubborn cases, try "running recalls": Sprint away while calling—most dogs chase moving targets. Add a visual cue like slapping your thigh. Remember, adolescent dogs (6–18 months) often regress; stay patient.
Ultimately, a reliable "come" transforms walks from stressful to joyful. It says, "I’m your safe place"—and that’s the heart of the human-dog bond.
Dogs struggle with “stay” because their brains are wired to “follow the pack”—and you’re their pack. To them, staying put while you move feels wrong
I was walking my friend’s Australian Shepherd, Luna, through a Seattle neighborhood last month when a jogger rounded the corner—and Luna erupted into barks
You’re walking your new rescue dog in the neighborhood park when a child on a scooter zips past, and suddenly your pup freezes, lips pulled back in a snarl, growling low in their throat.
You've just moved into a cozy apartment in downtown Chicago, excited to host your first dinner party. But as soon as the doorbell rings, your dog goes wild
It’s 7 AM on a Tuesday, and you’re already wide awake—not because of your alarm, but because your pup is standing at the window, barking nonstop at the neighbor walking their dog.
You’re strolling through your suburban neighborhood in Colorado, coffee in hand, when a kid on a bike rounds the corner. Suddenly, your pup tenses, hackles up